• Hello Guest! Did you know that ProjectKorra has an official Discord server? A lot of discussion about the official server, development process, and community discussion happens over there. Feel free to join now by clicking the link below.

    Join the Discord Server

Denied Dehydration

Status
Not open for further replies.
xD Cel Dx said:
your arguement is still invalid it would just be a water version of extraction but instead of taking Pure ore from ground, you're taking it from someones body... you've jsut helped explain it a little better thanks :D
Click to expand...
Can't this guy just be banned or something? He srsly thinks he knows everything and anyone who doesn't agree is "invalid".
xD Cel Dx said:
this suggestion is implimentable in minecraft and fits the criteria or being a canon move also ^_^ as we HAVE seen katara withdraw wateer from another body
Click to expand...
She didn't. The water the "extracted" wasn't in his cells. Back to biology class little kids *claps*
 
xD Cel Dx said:
your arguement is still invalid it would just be a water version of extraction but instead of taking Pure ore from ground, you're taking it from someones body... you've jsut helped explain it a little better thanks :D
Click to expand...

How do you know that they pull the metal out as opposed to having the earth spit out the metal?

Platinum, and natural untreated iron are a lot different. We've seen benders bend military grade iron which is way more treated. And you keep ignoring the fact about how we have no proof a waterbender can pull water out of a human body
 
Pickle9775 said:
How do you know that they pull the metal out as opposed to having the earth spit out the metal?

Platinum, and natural untreated iron are a lot different. We've seen benders bend military grade iron which is way more treated. And you keep ignoring the fact about how we have no proof a waterbender can pull water out of a human body
Click to expand...
Well, if you want to get technical, it would be possible through science. Skin is a semipermiable layer of the body. Sooo if you wanna step away from the show for a minute and look at the facts, this is possible. Needed? Depends.
 
White_Knight28 said:
Well, if you want to get technical, it would be possible through science. Skin is a semipermiable layer of the body. Sooo if you wanna step away from the show for a minute and look at the facts, this is possible. Needed? Depends.
Click to expand...

Yea, skin is semipermeable, but it usually only allows water to permeate in hypotonic or hypertonic enviorments are present. Cells only allow water to move in in and out via osmosis. Trying to force the water out would destory the cells, which happens to the plants that are used as sources of water.
 
Pickle9775 said:
Yea, skin is semipermeable, but it usually only allows water to permeate in hypotonic or hypertonic enviorments are present. Cells only allow water to move in in and out via osmosis. Trying to force the water out would destory the cells, which happens to the plants that are used as sources of water.
Click to expand...
Then you kill the animal and the move is even deadlier :P
 
EVERYONE here, treat each other nicely... You can easily disagree with someone without being disrespectful or rude? What is your problem with each other srsly?!

Stop fighting over a suggestion, this isn't kindergarden.
 
Adamskii6 said:
EVERYONE here, treat each other nicely... You can easily disagree with someone without being disrespectful or rude? What is your problem with each other srsly?!

Stop fighting over a suggestion, this isn't kindergarden.
Click to expand...

What debate where you reading? We are discussing this by using facts, not just all caps yelling at each other and calling each other invalid. Well a little.
 
Pickle9775 said:
How do you know that they pull the metal out as opposed to having the earth spit out the metal?

Platinum, and natural untreated iron are a lot different. We've seen benders bend military grade iron which is way more treated. And you keep ignoring the fact about how we have no proof a waterbender can pull water out of a human body
Click to expand...
because the move is called extraction, meaning something is taken from the original source. as for the water being pulled from a body, im pretttty sure if katara at a low waterbending skill level can extract water from someones lungs/mouth/stomach with ease it could be done in-game its also been seen on kyoshi island so please dont say we have no proof lol, also the thing about the cells being so small, the fact that waterbenders can pull water from thin air should be enough to cover that
 
xD Cel Dx said:
because the move is called extraction, meaning something is taken from the original source. as for the water being pulled from a body, im pretttty sure if katara at a low waterbending skill level can extract water from someones lungs/mouth/stomach with ease it could be done in-game its also been seen on kyoshi island so please dont say we have no proof lol, also the thing about the cells being so small, the fact that waterbenders can pull water from thin air should be enough to cover that
Click to expand...
Katara is one of the best waterbenders. Dunno how you think she is at a low level
 
White_Knight28 said:
Katara is one of the best waterbenders. Dunno how you think she is at a low level
Click to expand...
Yea she is. She healed/resurrected aang which was announced as a best healer after that event, unlocked/achieved bloodbending very quickly (well actually ,just about a minute after she was told about it ,lol), she pretty kept standing long enough in a fight with Pakku before she lost against him,and beated azula's ass during SOZINS COMET.
 
HydroMan said:
Yea she is. She healed/resurrected aang which was announced as a best healer after that event, unlocked/achieved bloodbending very quickly (well actually ,just about a minute after she was told about it ,lol), she pretty kept standing long enough in a fight with Pakku before she lost against him,and beated azula's ass during SOZINS COMET.
Click to expand...
Yep. The fact that we saw her do every sub-element of water also signifies that she was the best.
 
xD Cel Dx said:
because the move is called extraction, meaning something is taken from the original source. as for the water being pulled from a body, im pretttty sure if katara at a low waterbending skill level can extract water from someones lungs/mouth/stomach with ease it could be done in-game its also been seen on kyoshi island so please dont say we have no proof lol, also the thing about the cells being so small, the fact that waterbenders can pull water from thin air should be enough to cover that
Click to expand...

A few things.
What Katara did on kyoshi island, is the same thing as when you cough up water when you start to choke on it, nothing special
Water vapor and moisture in the air floats freely, not making up biological materials like cytoplasm or in the process of cellular respiration and would require you to over power the internal chemistry of so many cells. Plantbenders do this to plants which hold water in different ways not to mention they completely destroy where they go the water from, so its still too OP.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top